Kayak Fishing & Cell Phones, a Look at the "Water Resistant Cell Phones" of Today E-mail
Written by Chris Parson   
Friday, 24 December 2010 12:43

 

  kayak fishing cell phone rugby_2_1

Samsung

Rugy II

kayak fishing cell phone brigade 

Casio G’zOne

Briggade

kayak fishing cell phone ravine 

Casio G’zOne

Ravine

kayak fishing cell phone barragE  

Motorola

Barrage

Service Provider

AT&T

Verizon

Verizon

Verizon

Price Off Shelf

249.99

249.99

199.99

299.99

Price After Deals

99.99

199.99

149.99

129.99

Phone Style

Clamshell

Side Clamshell

Clamshell

Clamshell

Phone Rating

MIL- 810G

MIL-810F

MIL-810F

MIL-810F

Camera

2 mp

3.2 mp w/flash

3.2 mp w/flash

2.0 mp

Camera Zoom

1X

Yes

?

Yes

Video

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Video Live Share

Yes

Yes

?

Yes

Push to Talk

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Batt Talk Time

Up to 6 hrs

6 hrs

4.83 hrs

Up to 6.38 hrs

Batt Standby

21 days

31.67 days

20.42 days

22.25 days

Weight

3.52

5.49

4.6

4.2

Internal Memory

70 MB

123 MB

512 MB

?

Expandable Memory

32 GB

16 GB

Yes ?

16 GB

Bluetooth

Yes 2.0

Yes 2.1 + EDR

Yes 2.1 + EDR

Yes

Hands Free

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Speaker Phone

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Voice Dialing

Yes

Yes

?

 

Music Player

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Radio Service

Yes

Yes

Yes

?

 

Over the years I have learned that there are many ways to protect our cell phones during our time out on the water. Otter boxes, Aquapac’s, and leaving it on land will all work. However, if like me, you use your phone all too often, or rely on your phone as a lifeline, some of these solutions might not work for you. One thing to consider is buying a “tough phone” to start with.

Researching the various terms and electronics testing standards had me bouncing back and forth to wikipedia.org for days in an attempt to understand and condense this information and pass it on here. It really is frustrating shopping for phones and comparing the miriad of features that each one offers over the next. There are far too many variables when comparing all of a cell phone’s features in a heads up comparison and I lack both the capacity and the attention span to do so. My focus was to track down a few “tough phones” for our use on the water based on durability and basic features.

Most cell phone manufacturers are using a Military standard testing procedure called the (Mil-STD-810) defined by wikipedia.org as;  "Department of Defense Test Method Standard for Environmental Engineering Considerations and Laboratory Tests". “The military standard MIL-STD-810 test series addresses a broad range of environmental conditions that include: low pressure for altitude testing; exposure to high and low temperatures plus temperature shock (both operating and in storage); rain (including wind blown and freezing rain); humidity, fungus, salt fog for rust testing; sand and dust exposure; explosive atmosphere; leakage; acceleration; shock and transport shock (i.e., triangle/sine/square wave shocks); gunfire vibration; and random vibration.”

The way that I see it, a phone that can pass these tests should survive at least a year of the beating a kayak fishing enthusiast can bring down on it. With this in mind, I used these tests as a base for selecting the “tough phones” for this comparison. I’ll start with the Samsung Rugby as I have owned one for well over two years.

I have been using the Samsung Rugby (AT&T) and I haven’t been able to kill it yet. It’s been wet, submerged, dropped, kicked, drop kicked, crushed, and I haven’t had a problem. Recently, Samsung has upgraded the Rugby to the Rugby II. I have spent the last month with this latest version. I have to say that it appears to be just as solid a phone as its predecessor. It has also seen a few upgrades.

The second generation Samsung Rugby is a bit smaller, lighter and has had its software upgraded. This quad band phone is equipped with an advanced voice processing chip that delivers clear mobile calls by suppressing background noise(like wind), intermittent sounds (like a siren or nearby conversation), and echoes, allowing you to hear and be heard nearly anywhere. A feature that makes being heard while out on the water and in the elements no problem. Even in stiff winds, I can be heard clearly by the person that I am speaking with.

Samsung added voice commands for the GPS and dialing modes. There is a dedicated external button for taking self photos. This feature allows you to see the picture of you and your trophy catch in the screen as you take your picture. It’s perfect for sending payback shots of that trophy fish to your buddies that cancelled on you at the last minute. Feel free to take those shots while out on your kayak as water and slime won't effect this "tough phone". Also added were features such as extended video recording, live video sharing, music storage and playback, and even an FM radio feature.

When selecting a “tough phone” one might think that some of the bells and whistles will have to be sacrificed. That’s just not so. This phone is no “PDA”, but it comes with every feature that I need from a cell phone in the field and at home. I am very happy with the Rugby II. For those that are looking to purchase a “tough phone” for work or play, I highly recommend the Samsung Rugby II

 

Comments  

 
0 #1 Guest 2010-12-24 13:25
great work!
 
 
+3 #2 Guest 2011-01-04 15:42
If I may, I'd like to add comment about the Motorola Barrage. A few months ago, while Geocaching in the Jersy Pines, I was in a particularly wet area (shin deep water, wearing hip waders) I found the cache, was back in my Jeep when I realized i dropped the phone. I went back into the swamp, searched, but darkness fell. Went home, grabbed my wife's phone to call mine as I searched the swamp. I hunted for 2 hours in the darkness & got it to ring once, but couldn't located it. It started to rain hard, so I abandoned the search. i went out the next day, still raining, and after another 2 hours, I was about to give up, when I saw it sitting in about 1' deep water. When I retrieved it, I was delighted to flip it open & it was still on & operational! Total time about 12 hours underwater. All things should be made like that!
 
 
0 #3 Gringo 2011-01-05 07:47
I live in the Turks and Caicos Islands. We boat a lot. Also just got new Tandem Island!! We don't have Verizon or AT&T here. We have Cable and Wireless. Does anyone know if I could just take the SIM card out of my phone and have it work in one of these ruggedized ones?
 
 
0 #4 Guest 2011-01-10 13:41
I bought the motorola barrage in May 2020. The phone is advertised as waterproof and shockproof. The dealer @ Verizon specifically told me that the warranty does not cover water damage, and the front cover broke while I had it in the tool pocket of my carhartts at a high school football game. I have had motorola phones that were lighter and with more features last ten times longer. To me, not worth the extra price. I keep my phone in a pelican case while on the yak.
 

You must be registered to post a comment.


Login

Newsletter

Subscribe here to receive FREE email issues of Kayak Fishing Magazine.

Most Popular

Freedom Hawk 12 Review
  The company calls it the Freedom 12.  It’s the kayak I asked the company to build, sort of.  After using the 14 last winter in Texas I spoke with Dave Hadden...
Stand-N-Fish Kayak Fishing System
Stand-N-Fish has just completed the development of their exciting new, patent-pending, fishing system for kayaks. The innovative system incorporates pontoons and a leaning post in...
RTM K Largo Review
RTM Kayaks K LargoLength: 13’6” 415cmWidth: 30 ½” 78cmWeight” 55 lbs 25kgCapacity: 400 lbs 180kg   I had the opportunity to test drive the new K Largo by RTM kayaks....

Random

Minox introduces the DC 6033 Waterproof camera
The new Minox DC 6033 WP makes a new way of digital photography possible. Its solid and up to 10 meters waterproof housing can resist any dusts, water, sand or salt and is...
Mad Frog Gear Deluxe Pro Angler Board
If you have a Hobie Pro Angler, and you have ever kicked your rods while they were stored in the horizontal rod holders, you may need a set of the new Deluxe Pro Angler Boards....
The Malone HandiRack™
The HandiRack™ offers all the benefits of a traditional roof rack with none of the disadvantages. FEATURES: Half The Cost Of Metal Roof Racks Stores in the Trunk When Not In...

Latest Kayak Reviews

Pelican Castaway 100
 
4.0
Ascend FS10
 
4.0
Sun Dolphin Excursion 10
 
4.0
Santa Cruz Kayaks Raptor SOT
 
5.0
Old Town Predator 13
 
5.0
RTM Kayaks Tempo Angler
 
4.0
Hobie Mirage Revolution 13
 
3.0
Stealth Pro Fisha 575
 
4.0
Stealth Pro Fisha 475
 
4.0
Santa Cruz Kayaks Raptor SOT
 
5.0
Native Watercraft Manta Ray 14 Angler
 
5.0
Field and Stream Eagle Talon
 
5.0

Latest Equipment Reviews

Body Glove 3T Barefoot Max
 
5.0
Body Glove 3T Barefoot Warrior
 
5.0
Body Glove 3T Barefoot Warrior
 
3.0
Columbia Drainmaker
 
5.0
Sperry SON-R Sounder Shandal
 
4.0
Garmin VIRB Elite
 
4.0
Polaroid XS100
 
4.0
Backwater Paddles Assault Hand Paddle
 
5.0
Backwater Paddles Assault Hand Paddle
 
5.0
Stohlquist Piseas
 
4.0
Wheeleez Tuff Tire Kayak Cart
 
5.0
Boga Grip
 
4.0